The CJP effect: SC orders no children be sent to detention camps in Assam Interim order protects children excluded from NRC; Attorney General required to record an undertaking

06, Jan 2020 | Sanchita Kadam

The Supreme Court has passed an interim order protecting children excluded from Assam’s National Register of Citizens (NRC) from being sent to detention centres. CJP had moved an application seeking directions from the apex court, drawing attention to Constitutional and legal obligations. We had prayed, specifically, that no child  excluded from the NRC is either sent to a detention camp, or separated from their parents in Assam.

In November 2019, Citizens for Justice and Peace (CJP) had filed an Intervention Application for directions in a writ petition case Assam Public Works vs. UOI (274 of 2009). This application filed by CJP in the Supreme Court concerns cases of children excluded from the NRC, even when their parents and, in some instances, the relatives/guardians of the children are part of the NRC. Advocate Aparna Bhat appeared for CJP in the Supreme Court.

In view of the points put forth by CJP, the apex court considered the issue and in the interim period before giving a final decision in the Intervention Application, directed Assam government to ensure that children whose parents’ names are included in the NRC in Assam are not sent to detention camps.

Now that the final NRC has been published, and 19,06,657 people have been excluded from the final list, CJP’s campaign has become even more focused. Our objective now, is to help these excluded people defend their citizenship before Foreigners’ Tribunals. For this we have already started conducting a series of workshops to train paralegals to assist people at FTs. We will also be publishing a multi-media training manual containing simplified aspects of legal procedure, evidentiary rules, and judicial precedents that will ensure the appeals filed against the NRC exclusions in the FTs are comprehensive and sound, both in fact and in law. This will assist our paralegals, lawyers and the wider community in Assam to negotiate this tortuous process. For this we need your continued support. Please donate now to help us help Assam.

What the application says

Through this application, CJP sought to bring to the notice of the Supreme Court that Assam is in a state of humanitarian crisis as a direct result of mass exclusions from the final list of NRC published on August 31, 2019.

CJP even submitted that almost 100 persons have lost their lives as a direct result of the citizenship issues involved in the publication of the NRC which include 27 recorded deaths in Assam’s Detention Camps, which has now risen to 29 recorded deaths.

CJP brought to fore the point that children have been excluded from the NRC Final List even when their parents are included which amounted to direct contravention of the State’s obligation towards children as envisaged under Article 15 (3), Article 39 (e) & (f), Article 45 and Article 47 of the Constitution of India, and the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015. Along with the Application was also attached a list of 61 of such excluded children.

In order to illustrate the severity of the issue, a detailed list of 61 such children themselves excluded from the list, while parents were included. The case studies of 3 children were also detailed to help the apex court understand the ground realities and sufferings of families separated due to this arbitrary process of NRC.

These included the story of Hasmat Ali who has three minor children. While his and his wife’s name was included in NRC, their children’s names found no place in it and since then he has had to rush from one hearing to another which are held at far-away places, collecting all kinds of documents, incurring large expenses, even taking money on loan, to ensure his children do no end up in detention camp. Each of the 61 children excluded from NRC have a similar story of struggle and financial distress from which it will take a much longer time to recover.

To strengthen their point CJP also cited the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child which India has ratified which makes it obligatory under Article 8 for all State Parties to respect the right of the child to preserve his or her identity, including nationality, name and family relations as recognized by law without unlawful interference. Also, Article 9 holds State Parties responsible for ensuring that a child is not separated from his or her parents against their will, except when competent authorities subject to judicial review determine, in accordance with applicable law and procedures, that such separation is necessary for the best interests of the child.

Relief sought

The said application prayed the apex court to pass orders to the office of the Coordinator to immediately take steps to ensure that no child is left out of the NRC especially in cases where the parents/guardians/caregivers are included in the list. It also asked that in the interim, the court pass orders directing state of Assam not to take any coercive action against the children or separate them from their families.

SC’s order

In its order, given on the January 6 hearing, the Supreme Court directed the Assam government to ensure that no children of parents whose names have been included in the final NRC list be sent to detention centres or be separated from their parents until the said application by CJP is fully considered.

CJP’s Assam connect

In the said application, CJP has made a mention of their campaign in Assam to help those affected by NRC process. About the NRC final list, it says, “the Final List published on 31.08.2019 has unreasonably and unfairly excluded the names of certain sections of persons which essentially results in violation of the basic principle of family unification by excluding members of a family.”

CJP’s work in Assam includes attending to calls received on a toll-free helpline number created by CJP so people can reach out to them for help. It is because of the inaccessibility of the topography of the State to vast sections of the marginalised and agrarian population that the idea of a Toll Free Helpline number was conceived.  CJP’s on-ground work continues on a month to month basis under difficult circumstances which amounts to providing para-legal aid to marginalised sections of the rural population, 62% of the affected being women.

The Supreme Court order may be read here:

 

The Intervention Application may be read here:

 

Related:

CJP in action in Assam: Reaching remote villages to render counselling and aid

Person with two names confuses NRC officials

CJP reaches out to a declared foreigner whose brothers declared citizens

CJP in Action: CJP moves NHRC against police excesses in Daryaganj 

CJP in Action: NHRC takes note of complaints, issues notice to UP police chief 

Teesta Setalvad addresses massive crowd on CAA, NPR-NRC

CJP continues building grassroots movement against NRC-NPR and CAA